Research Article
Fifteen Atypical Pulmonary Hydatidosis Lesions Mimicking Lung Cancer and Lesions
Ülkü Yazici1, Serdar Özkan2*, Özgür Ö. Yildiz3, Ertan Aydin4, Yücel Akkaş5 and Nurettin
Karaoğlanoğlu3
1Department of Thoracic Surgery, Ataturk Training and Research Hospital for Chest Disease and Chest Surgery,
Turkey
2Department of Thoracic Surgery, Karatay University, Turkey
3Department of Thoracic Surgery, Dışkapı Yıldırım Bayezit Training and Research Hospital, Turkey
4Department of Thoracic Surgery, Koru Hospital, Turkey
5Department of Thoracic Surgery, Numune Training and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey
*Corresponding author: Serdar Özkan, Department of Thoracic Surgery, Karatay University, Konya, Turkey
Published: 14 Jul, 2017
Cite this article as: Yazici Ü, Özkan S, Yildiz ÖÖ, Aydin
E, Akkaş Y, Karaoğlanoğlu N. Fifteen
Atypical Pulmonary Hydatidosis Lesions
Mimicking Lung Cancer and Lesions.
Clin Surg. 2017; 2: 1563.
Abstract
Background: Hydatid cyst disease, which is mostly caused by Echinococcus granulosus, may result
in high morbidity rates particularly in endemic regions, and mortality depending on its size and
on the organs where it is located. While the disease can be diagnosed radiologically because of
typical symptoms, it becomes more difficult to distinguish it from lung malignancies as the cysts
get complicated.
Methods: 15 cases of pulmonary hydatid cyst that underwent clinical and radiological examinations
and surgery after being diagnosed with lung abscess and lung cancer between 2008 and 2014 in our
Thoracic Surgery Clinic were retrospectively reviewed.
Results: Radiological features of the 80% of the cases in thoracic CT were mimicking tumour
in the form of thick walled cavitary lesion, hilar mass, cystic necrotic solid mass or solid mass;
and 20% of them had radiological features mimicking abscess in the form of thin walled cavitary
lesion. Lobectomy was performed for one case, wedge resection was performed for two cases and
cystotomy-capitonnage was performed for 12 cases.
Conclusion: It should be kept in mind that pulmonary hydatid cyst clinically and radiologically can
mimic lung cancer and lung abscess.
Introduction
Hydatid cyst disease, which could develop in almost all organs especially in liver and lung by forming cystic lesions, has got high morbidity and mortality rates and it is a significant public health issue. While there could be symptoms depending on the location and the size of the unruptured cysts, the majority of the cases are asymptomatic. Pressure on neighboring organs or expectoration of the cyst due to rupture are among the main symptoms. Diagnosis is usually through lung graphics and Computer Tomography (CT). Radiological images of the cystic lesions are homogenous, round or oval and well demarcated. Atypical or complicated hydatid cysts in lungs could clinically and radiologically resemble other lung malignancies [1,2]. Similarity of complicated hydatid cyst lesions with other lung malignancies causes difficulties in diagnosis and planning the surgical treatment.
Material and Methods
In this study, 15 cases of pulmonary hydatid cyst that underwent clinical and radiological examinations and surgery after being diagnosed with lung abscess and lung cancer between 2008 and 2014 in our Thoracic Surgery Clinic were retrospectively reviewed. At the diagnosis stage, lung graphics, Computer Tomography and Positron Emission Tomography (PET-CT) were performed. Tran’s thoracic needle biopsy was applied for three cases. The cases included in this study are the ones with hydatid cysts whose clinical and radiological features are not consistent with the symptoms and radiology of hydatid cysts and the cases which mimic lung cancer or lung abscess. The cases evaluated as lung abscess after the radiological examination underwent anti biotherapy for 4-6 weeks, and in case of no significant change in radiological findings, surgical treatment was decided. Surgical procedures were planned depending on the localisation and the size of the lesion and different surgical procedures including cystotomy-capitonnage and lobectomy were performed. Cases (12) were diagnosed with hydatid cyst in intraoperative stage, while three of them were diagnosed with hydatid cyst in the postoperative stage.
Figure 1
Figure 2
Figure3
Results
The average age of the 15 cases included in this study was calculated as 49.3 (17-63), 8 of the cases are male and 7 of them are female, 33% of the cases (n=5) complained of cough, 27% of the cases (n=4) chest pain, 27% of the cases (n=4) hemoptysis and 13% (n=2) chills and fever. 60% of the lesions were located in the right lung. Radiological features of the 80% of the cases (n=12) in thoracic CT were mimicking tumour in the form of thick walled cavitary lesion, hilar mass, cystic necrotic solid mass or solid mass (Figure 1 and 2); and 20% of them (n=3) had radiological features mimicking abscess in the form of thin walled cavitary lesion (Figure 3). Characteristics of the cases enrolled in the study are located in Table 1. Positron emission tomography was performed for five cases out of 12, clinical and radiological findings of which mimic lung cancer. FDG retention in PET-CT was calculated between 2-7,8 (SUVmax). None of the cases was detected with cystic or mass lesion in addition to lung lesion. Bronchoscopy was performed for all cases in the preoperative stage. No pathological findings were found as a result of bronchoscopy. Tran’s thoracic needle biopsy was performed for three cases, radiological features of which resembled to solid mass. In the histopathological evaluation of biopsy materials, no diagnostic results were obtained in relation to malignancy and hydatid cyst. In light of existing radiological findings, lobectomy was performed for one case, wedge resection was performed for two cases and cystotomy-capitonnage was performed for 12 cases. Pathological results of all cases were reported as hydatid cyst.
Table 1
Discussion
The majority of hydatid cyst diseases are caused by the larval stage
of E. Granulosus affecting mostly the liver and lungs, respectively.
While the majority of the cases have solitary lesions, there are also
cases having multiple lesions. In 60% of the cases, it is located in the
right lung and in 20% of the cases the lesions are bilateral [3,4]. In all
15 cases included in this study, the lesions were unilateral and solitary
and 60% of them were located in the right lung.
Lung hydatid cysts usually are not symptomatic. Symptoms start
to appear after the size of the cyst reaches 5cm and creates pressure
in the neighboring organs or in the case of ruptured and complicated
the cystic lesion [5]. Depending on the size and the localisation of the
cyst, non-specific symptoms including cough, hemoptysis and chest
pain occur [6]. The most frequent symptoms in the majority of the
cases were non-specific ones such as cough, whilst some cases had
symptoms such as fever and shivers which could occur after the cyst
rupture.
In diagnosis of hydatid cyst, tests such as indirect hemaglutination
or indirect fluorescent antibody can be applied [7]. However due to
the lack of specific diagnosis in the preoperative stage of the cases
according to the clinical and radiological findings, serological tests
for the diagnosis of hydatid cyst could not be performed. Having said
that, despite the positive serological tests for Echinococcus granulosus,
there are reports arguing that serological tests, which identify large
cell lung carcinoma, can give false positive results [8].
Since the clinical and laboratory findings are not specific in
the diagnosis of hydatid cyst, radiological scan gains importance at
the diagnosis stage. Cysts that are not complicated are seen as well
demarcated round or homogeneous masses in computer tomography
and lung graphics. Larger cysts can result in atelactasy in lungs,
mediastinal shift or pleural effusion depending on the level of the
pressure on the neighbouring tissue. Lung graphics of the complicated
cysts can show air-fluid level, water lily or meniscus signs. Ruptured
cysts can appear as mass or abscess in computer tomography. Due to
the fact that none of our cases had typical radiological findings for
hydatid cyst and there were images mimicking abscess or tumour
in direct graphics and computer tomography, the diagnostic and
surgical approach to the cases showed differences. Five cases that
were thought to be malignant were examined in PET-CT and the
SUVmax values of these examinations supported the malignancy
diagnosis [2-8].
Due to the rise in glucoses metabolism in the malign pulmonary
nodules, the FDG retention in the nodule also shows increase.
Lesions with FDG retention with SUVmax value higher than 2,5-
3 in PET-CT are usually evaluated as malign [9]. However, as a
result of rise in FDG retention due to infectious and granulomatosis
and inflammation, false positive results are not unexpected. The
most frequent false positive results are seen in diseases including
tuberclosis, sarcoidosis, aspergillus and parasitary diseases [10].
Local inflammation caused by cyst rupture in our cases resulted in
positive PET-BT results for malignancy. Similar to our study, there
are reports on breast carcinoma cases which were initially evaluated
as pulmonary metastatic lesion in PET-CT and later was diagnosed as
hydatid cyst during the surgical stage [11], or cases which underwent
surgery due to the lesion which showed pulmonary hyper metabolic
retention in PET-CT but later diagnosed as infected consolidated
hydatid cyst during the pathological examination [12]. In another
study conducted on this issue, it was reported that hydatid cyst
disease can easily be confused with thoracic empyema, mediastinal
mass, tuberculosis pleurisy and thoracic wall tumour General Surgery [13].
It should be kept in mind that pulmonary hydatid cyst in endemic
regions clinically and radiologically can mimic lung cancer and lung
abscess.
References
- Kilinç O, Döskaya M, Sakar A, Yorgancioglu A, Halilçolar H, Caner A, et al. Three atypical pulmonary hydatidosis lesions mimicking bronchial cancer from Turkey. New Microbiol. 2009;32:229-33.
- Ozkok A, Gul E, Okumus G, Yekeler E, Gulluoglu MG, Kiyan E, et al. Disseminated alveolar echinococcosis mimicking a metastatic malignancy. Intern Med. 2008;47:1495-97.
- Morar R, Feldman C. Pulmonary echinococcosis. Eur Respir J. 2003;21:1069-77.
- Deshmane JV. Multiple pulmonary hydatid cysts. Postgrad Med J. 1967;43:774-8.
- Sayek I. Hydatid Cyst Disease: Clinical Aspects. Echinococcosis. Altintas N, Tinar R, Coker A, Editors. Publications of Turkish Society of Hydatidology, Izmir. 2004;141-7.
- Çobanoglu U, Sayir F, Mergan D. Diagnostic dilemma: analysis of 11 cases of hydatid disease. Turkiye Parazitol Derg. 2011;35:164-8.
- Esgin M, Aktas M, Coskun S. The investigation of antibody presence in the sera of patients with a suspicion of cystic echinococcosis by using indirect hemaglutination test (IHA). Turkiye Parazitol Derg. 2007;31:283-7.
- Singh, Srinivas R, Bal A, Aggarwal AN. Lung carcinoma mimicking hydatid cyst: a case report and review of the literature. Med Oncol. 2009;26:424-8.
- Love C, Tomas MB, Tronco GG, Palestro CJ. FDG PET of infection and inflammation. Radiographics. 2005;25:1357-68.
- Kadam SG, Basu S, Joshi JM. Doughnut sign on FDG-PET scan in a ruptured lung hydatid cyst. Indian J Chest Dis Allied Sci. 2012;54:185-7.
- Kurt Y, Sücüllü I, Filiz AI, Urhan M, Akin ML. Pulmonary echinococcosis mimicking multiple lung metastasis of breast cancer: the role of fluoro-deoxy-glucose positron emission tomography. World J Surg Oncol. 2008;6:7.
- Rangarajan V, Dua S, Purandare NC, Shah S, Sharma AR. Pulmonary hydatid cyst detected on FDG PET-CT. Clin Nucl Med. 2010;35:298-9.
- Gürsoy S, Üçvet A, Türk F, Tözüm H, Erbaycu AE, Basok O. Diagnostic dilemma of hydatic disease:analysis of 16 patients. Turkiye Klinikleri J Med Sci. 2009;29:457-63.