Case Report
Surgical Management of Peroneal Nerve Injury in Complex Sports Knee Injuries
Nath RK* and Somasundaram C
Department Brachial Plexus and Peripheral Nerve Surgery, Texas Nerve and Paralysis Institute, USA
*Corresponding author: Rahul Kumar Nath, Department Brachial Plexus and Peripheral Nerve Surgery, Texas Nerve and Paralysis Institute, 6400. Fannin st. Houston, TX- 77030, USA
Published: 21 May, 2016
Cite this article as :Nath RK, Somasundaram C. Surgical
Management of Peroneal Nerve Injury
in Complex Sports Knee Injuries. Clin
Surg. 2016; 1: 1008.
Abstract
Objective: SOur study analyzes 6 operative knee-level peroneal nerve lesions and foot drop patients treated at our clinic.
Introduction: The most frequent lower extremity injuries resulting from sports and related recreational activities is peroneal nerve entrapment. This can be acute or can arise due to chronic
overuse. Numerous etiologies have been identified. However, compression remains the main cause,
which generally results in acute complete or partial foot drop.
Method and Patients: This is a retrospective study of a series of 6 consecutive patients with foot drop resulting from sports and related injuries. For all patients, the preoperative clinical examination
and electromyographic evaluation were performed. Nerve conduction and clinical function results
showed injury to the peroneal nerve. Peroneal nerve decompression was performed in these patients
in our study between 2007 and 2014.
Results: Overall statistically significant clinical and functional improvement from pre-operative MRC grade 2.5 ± 0.8 to post-operative MRC grade 4.0 ± 0.9 (P value 0.007) was achieved.
Conclusion: Results of peroneal nerve decompression in sports injury foot drop patients in our
study produced remarkable clinical and functional recovery in foot anti-gravity (MRC grade 4.0)
and walking gait.
Conclusion: Results of peroneal nerve decompression in sports injury foot drop patients in our study produced remarkable clinical and functional recovery in foot anti-gravity (MRC grade 4.0)
and walking gait.
Keywords: Sports injuries; Peroneal nerve; Decompression; Knee injury; Foot drop
Introduction
Sports injuries to the lower limbs can be acute or can occur due to chronic overuse. The most
common cause of sports injuries are gymnastics, soccer, baseball, volleyball, football and running.
Peroneal nerve lesion is the most frequent and common in the lower extremities and has a worse
prognosis than those in the upper extremities [1,2]. This is the third most common entrapment in
the body [3] and causes antigravity weakness to the tibialis anterior muscle, resulting in foot drop.This has devastating effects on patient activities, especially their profession in athletes. Typically,
such lesions are difficult to manage successfully. The method of treatment is dependent on the
mechanism and degree of the nerve injury.
Predicting and achieving spontaneous recovery of peroneal nerve function can be difficult.
Usually, it appears as an entrapment neuropathy and the symptoms can be improved by traditional
treatments. Some of these knee and foot drop injuries are complicated and surgical exploration is
necessary [4]. These may not be as easily dealt with if surgery is delayed beyond 3-4 weeks [5]. We report here the results of a retrospective analysis of surgically managed 6 patients, who had knee
injuries and foot drop resulting from sports and related recreational activities.
Method and Patients
This is a retrospective study of a series of 6 consecutive patients with knee injuries and foot drop. These patients in our present study had sports-related traumatic injuries associated with football, volleyball, soccer and running. All 6 patients underwent peroneal nerve decompression, micro-neurolysis, neuroplasty with us between 2007 and 2014. For all patients, the preoperative clinical examination and electromyographic evaluation were performed. Nerve conduction and clinical function results showed injury to the peroneal nerve in all 6 patients. Preoperative duration of injury and foot drop reported by the patients was recorded (between 2 weeks and 4 months). Further patient demographics, including age, sex, mechanism and extent of the injury are provided in (Table 1). Ankle eversion, inversion and dorsiflexion, toe extension, flexion and plantar flexion were clinically evaluated by the lead author (RKN) [6] using MRC scale for muscle strength pre- operatively and at least 6 months after surgery.
Table 1
Table 1
Grading of foot drop in patients resulting from sports injuries, who underwent peroneal nerve decompression.
Duration 1 day – 4 months; Follow-up 6 – 18 months: pre-op MRC grade 2.5 ± 0.8; post-op MRC grade 4.0 ± 0.9 (P value 0.007)
Figure 1
Figure 1
21-year-old male patient with right peroneal nerve injury and foot drop.
Fell on sand while playing beach volleyball.Upper panel, ABC: before surgery.Lower panel, DEF: after surgery (peroneal nerve decompression, microneurolysis, neuroplasty).
Statistical analysis
Statistical analysis was performed using Analyse-It plugin (Leeds, United Kingdom) for Microsoft Excel 2003 software. A P- value of < 0.05 was considered as statistically significant.
Results
Overall statistically significant clinical and functional
improvement from pre-operative MRC grade 2.5 ± 0.8 to postoperative
MRC grade 4.0 ± 0.9 (P value 0.007) was achieved. The
improvement of the injured foot movement for each of these 6
patients is shown separately in Table 1 and Figure 1, and walking Gait
in Figure 2 (from videos).
Patient 1, a 21-year old male volleyball player had an acute injury
and had “0” muscle strength in MRC grade for toe extension, ankle
eversion and dorsiflexion before surgery. “0” indicates no movement.
EMG also indicated a complete right peroneal nerve injury. This
might be the impact of the continuous physical activity (running) and there was no
accident involved. EMG data confirmed the left peroneal nerve injury.
Patient 3, a 28-year old female patient had external compression of
left peroneal nerve resulting from a motorcycle ride. Patients 4, 5 and
6 are all male football players, had foot drop due to acute injury.
Overall, in all 5 acute injury patients (except patient # 2, chronic
use), toe extension, ankle eversion and dorsiflexion (foot movement
category 1) were severely damaged (mean MRC 2/5) due to peroneal
nerve involvement (Table 1 and 2) when compared to the other foot
movements, toe and plantar flexion and ankle inversion (tibial nerve
functions, category 2), mean MRC 4/5 (Table 1 and 2). The recovery
after peroneal nerve decompression was 3.5/5 and 4+/5 muscle
strength in foot movements in category 1 and 2 respectively.
All 5 acute injury patients in our study had MRC grade of 4 to
5 pre-operatively, in performing ankle inversion, toe and plantar
flexion in spite of their poor performance in toe extension, ankle
eversion and dorsiflexion (mean MRC 2/5). This pre-operative
clinical evaluation indicates that these patients did not have tibial
nerve injury. Therefore, in addition to EMG data, this confirms that
foot drop in these patients was caused by peroneal nerve injury.
The improvement after peroneal nerve decompression was MRC
3.5/5 from MRC 2/5 in terms of toe extension, ankle eversion and
dorsiflexion in these 5 patients with acute injury, whereas tibial nerve
muscle movements such as ankle inversion, toe and plantar flexion
remained the same (MRC 4+/5) after the surgery as there was no
tibial nerve involvement.
Figure 2
Figure 2
21-year-old male patient with right peroneal nerve injury and foot drop.Fell on sand while playing beach volleyball.Upper panel, walking Gait before surgery.Lower panel, walking Gait after surgery (peroneal nerve decompression,microneurolysis, neuroplasty).
Table 2
Discussion
Continuous physical activities such as walking, cycling or
running and the high impact sports activities involving lower limbs
can damage a normal joint. We [6] have previously reported the
successful outcome of nerve transfer to the deep peroneal nerve in
14-foot drop patients. Among all knee injury and foot drop patients
treated at our clinic between 2008 and 2014, we present here only
injuries resulted from sports and related recreational activities, and
who were candidates for peroneal nerve decompression. Peroneal
nerve injury is a well-identified complication in and around the knee
region in sports activities. Some acute and severe sports injuries have
the same pattern of injury as motor vehicle accidents [5], for example,
the female motorcycle rider in our present study
Though, patients benefit from nonsurgical treatments, surgical
decompression has been considered for stubborn patients and
those with compressive masses, acute lacerations, or severe nerve
conduction changes [7]. Results of the surgical decompression
and neurolysis [8,9] have been reported typically with favorable
outcomes. Gosk et al. [9] demonstrated efficacy of 68.5% (61 of 89
patients) by neurolysis in lesions to lower extremities. Thoma et al.
[10,11] described significant improvement of ankle dorsiflexion in 19 of
20 patients with common peroneal nerve palsies treated exclusively
with peroneal nerve decompression. A strong correlation between
ultimate therapeutic results and timing of the operation was reported
[8,9]. Further, encouraging results were reported when the delay was
not more than 8 months [8,9]. Preoperative duration of injury and
foot drop reported by our patients was recorded (between 2 weeks
and 4 months). Tendon and nerve transfers are used only in the
setting of failed decompression or for patients with a poor prognosis
for nerve recovery [6,7].
Conclusion
Overall statistically significant clinical improvement to MRC grade 4.0 ± 0.9 (P value 0.007) was achieved after peroneal nerve decompression, micro-neurolysis and neuroplasty. Functional recovery was remarkable in foot anti-gravity and walking gait in these patients.
References
- Sedel L. The surgical management of nerve lesions in the lower limbs.Clinical evaluation, surgical technique and results. Int Orthop. 1985; 9: 159-170.
- umble TE, Vanderhooft E, Khan U. Sural nerve grafting for lower extremity nerve injuries. J Orthop Trauma. 1995; 9: 158-163.
- MB, Wilbourn AJ. Common peroneal mononeuropathy: a clinical and electrophysiologic study of 116 lesions. Neurology. 1988; 38: 1723-1728.
- Y, Sakakida K. Sports and peripheral nerve injury. Am J Sports Med. 1983; 11: 420-426.
- ddle BC, Bidwell TA, Chapman JR. Knee dislocations: where are the lesions? A prospective evaluation of surgical findings in 63 cases. J Orthop Trauma. 2003; 17: 198-202.
- RK, Lyons AB, Paizi M. Successful management of foot drop by nerve transfers to the deep peroneal nerve. J Reconstr Microsurg. 2008; 24: 419-427.
- C, Roth C, Scott B. Peroneal Nerve Palsy. Evaluation and Management. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2016; 24: 1-10.
- J, Rutowski R. Penetrating injuries to the nerves of the lower extremity: principles of diagnosis and treatment. Ortop Traumatol Rehabil. 2005; 7: 651-655.
- J, Rutowski R, Rabczynski J. The lower extremity nerve injuries - own experience in surgical treatment. Folia Neuropathol. 2005; 43: 148-152.
- A, Fawcett S, Ginty M, Veltri K. Decompression of the common peroneal nerve: experience with 20 consecutive cases. Plast Reconstr Surg 2001; 107: 1183-1189.
- Moore KL (1992) Clinically Orientated Anatomy, Third Edition, Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, pp.413, 464-466, 493-496.